Warm oak floors, white wainscoting and a linen armchair beside a closed window overlooking snow and a bare sugar maple.

Vilas Park's Lagoon Skating May Move to the Old Speed Skating Track This Winter

"A leaf that gets frozen into the ice, on a sunny day, even when it's 20 degrees out, it will burn a hole right in that ice," Chad Hughes, operations manager for Madison's Parks Division, told the Wisconsin State Journal this fall. In late October, parts of the Vilas Park lagoon were thick with aquatic plants and fallen leaves. That came about two months before outdoor skating season usually starts. According to the same story, the city is waiting to see how much of that vegetation dies off and sinks before the water freezes.

The Vilas lagoon has always been harder to freeze than Madison's other skating ponds. It had a little help from weed cutting before. That help is gone this year, so the city has changed its winter plan. The rinks next to the shelter are the reliable ice at Vilas this season. If the lagoon is skated at all, it will most likely be at the far end, on a stretch that hasn't had a regular tenant in more than a decade.

A healthier Lake Wingra makes for rougher ice

Dane County will no longer cut weeds at Lake Wingra, and that includes the Vilas Park lagoon, Hughes told the State Journal. The paper described the change as good news for the lake. The county used cutting to manage invasive and unwanted plants. The lake ecosystem has improved enough in recent years that costly mechanical work is no longer considered necessary.

A neighborhood update gave a second reason. District 13 Alder Tag Evers posted it on the city's council blog on October 26. It shares a resident's report from an October 15 meeting with Parks staff, which says Dane County can no longer get a DNR permit to remove weeds in the lagoon because the lagoon is now too shallow. The same report says current projections call for a warmer winter, though nothing is guaranteed.

Either way, the weeds stay. For skaters, that matters because of how plants behave in ice. "Our experience with having lake weeds freeze into the ice is that it provides really low-quality ice," Hughes said. Plants are darker than ice and absorb more solar energy, so the ice around them melts.

Vilas was already a few inches behind Tenney

Madison has two main pond rinks, the lagoons at Vilas Park and Tenney Park, and skating is also offered on the Warner Park lagoon. Even when the county was still cutting weeds, Vilas didn't freeze as well as Tenney. Hughes explained why to the State Journal. The Vilas lagoon is shallower and more stagnant, with only a few feet of water over a few more feet of muck. That dark layer just under the surface absorbs heat and slows ice formation.

He put a number on the gap: "On days where we have 8 to 10 inches of really good ice at Tenney, we may struggle to get even 4 to 5 inches out here. We usually can't open up as early or stay open as long as Tenney."

The city's own guidance on declaring rinks and lagoons open shows how thin that margin is. Staff measure the ice at multiple points, and grooming machines need a consistent 5 to 6 inches. On the day Tenney has 8 to 10 inches, Vilas may barely reach the depth the equipment needs. Weeds frozen into the ice now cut into that margin from another direction.

Temperature swings make it worse. "What really is challenging for us are the swings," Hughes said. If a warm spell costs a lagoon even a few feet of ice along the shoreline, he said, "it can take a week or more, sometimes, to recover." The city's lined rinks recover much faster.

How the ice at Vilas is laid out this winter

Here is the Parks Division plan, drawn from the State Journal story and the October 26 council update:

Ice surface Where it sits Plan for this winter
Hockey rink Between the shelter and Lake Wingra Set up as usual
General skating rink Between the shelter and Lake Wingra Set up as usual
Lagoon near the shelter The usual lagoon skating area Vegetation left in place around the edge to discourage use, with warning signs at any unsafe ice
Former speed-skating stretch Across the bridge from the shelter, between the bridges and the zoo Groomed for skating if the ice gets thick enough

According to the council update, skate rentals will still run out of the shelter. Skaters may get onto the ice from a different spot if the far end opens. The State Journal reported that the speed-skating stretch is thought to be a little deeper, and so more likely to freeze, than the area near the shelter where people usually skate.

Hughes was candid about the odds. He isn't sure the lagoon will produce usable ice this winter. If it does, the city will open it as conditions allow. Madison's skating season usually runs from about mid-December to mid-February, so the answer won't come for several weeks.

The far end has been quiet since 2012

The Vilas speed-skating track had a main tenant for many years. The Madison Speed Skating Club last used it in 2012. A few years later, the club's president told the State Journal that the club left partly because Madison winters had become less dependable.

Now the same stretch may be the last good ice on the lagoon, and for a similar reason. Hughes connects the problem to a warmer, more variable climate that affects all winter recreation in Madison. He also told the State Journal it may push the city to rethink some winter investments, including lagoon skating at Vilas. "At what point is the effort that we put into maintaining ice more than what we get for winter recreation?" he asked. He followed with a commitment: "But we are committed to try and provide lagoon skating, definitely this year, and consider options in the future if this year really is the struggle that we think it could be."

What a dredge would take

If the lagoon doesn't produce usable ice, Hughes said the city could try other fixes in later years. One is lowering the water level temporarily to help clear vegetation. Another is dredging.

The council update describes Parks as being in the early stages of working out what dredging part of the lagoon would require. Dredging would reduce weeds, help the fish population and support skating. It would also be expensive, especially if tests show contaminated sediment. Parks believes that if dredging happens, it makes sense to do it together with building a new shelter. Staff think the work would likely help the lagoon year-round, but they didn't want to promise results this early.

The Board of Park Commissioners adopted the Vilas Park master plan on March 10, 2021. Its lagoon concept is a "50-50" balance of open water and wetland vegetation, with more study of dredging depth and plant management before any work begins. The city's 2026 adopted capital budget includes a $14 million Vilas Park Master Plan project, labeled as phased implementation.

The project has also hit a setback. Before construction, the master plan requires a cultural resources study. The council update reports that the national archaeology firm hired for that study unexpectedly went bankrupt. The archaeologist who took core samples in September still has them, and Parks is working out how to keep the study moving.

The rest of Madison's ice

Madison offers free skating at 20 rinks and designated lagoons in 14 parks. The city's ice skating page lists each one with its own status. Parks asks skaters to check that status online or call the Parks office before heading out, and rinks and lagoons close when meltwater is visible. Here is how last season's setup looked, according to that page:

  • Designated lagoons: Tenney, Vilas and Warner.
  • Hockey rinks: Elver, Olbrich, Tenney, Vilas and Westmorland.
  • Warming shelters with skate rentals: Door Creek, Elver, Tenney and Vilas, staffed Wednesday through Friday 4 to 8 p.m., Saturday noon to 8 p.m. and Sunday noon to 6 p.m., depending on weather and ice.
  • Rental prices: $6 for adults, $3 for youth 15 and younger, $2 for each additional hour, and $3 for hockey sticks at Elver, Tenney and Vilas.
  • Free loaner skates: Olbrich, Rennebohm, Warner and Westmorland.
  • Other general skating rinks: Goodman, Heritage Heights, Hillington Green, Nakoma, Sunset and Wexford.

Volunteers keep much of this ice going, and the city credits its Adopt Ice Partnership on the same page.

Madison Ice Arena runs public skating sessions with rentals. Hartmeyer Ice Arena offers public skating for all ages, rents skates for $3 and posts session times on its calendar.

One date is already set. Clean Lakes Alliance's free Frozen Assets Festival returns to The Edgewater on Saturday, February 6, 2027, with free skating and skate rental, figure-skating demonstrations and learn-to-skate sessions. At Vilas, a mid-December check of the city's status page will show whether the far end of the lagoon froze.

Winter at Vilas Park is part of what makes the neighborhoods around Lake Wingra feel like home, and we pay attention to these changes the same way our neighbors do. If you're thinking about what your own home near the park is worth this season, ENZco Real Estate is happy to talk it through. Request your free home valuation.

Ready to Move Forward?

Real estate can feel tricky, but it doesn’t have to. With our team on your side, you get experience, creativity, and someone who’s got your back the whole way. We’ll help you navigate the market, make smart choices, and find a home that really fits your life.

Follow Me on Instagram